There is no pre-formed collective will of the people. It consists of an infinite multiplicity of interests, aspirations, desires, and real needs. This means there’s no one capable of grasping the totality of it. The collective will of the people cannot be embraced or understood by any one person or combination of people. In the past, some have claimed to have a “genius brain” that can act as an ideological and theoretical vanguard for the people, illuminating the struggle of the masses for them, on their behalf.
This kind of enlightened vanguardism implies bureaucracy, a separate intellectual class that understands better than others, one that knows how to properly use theory to manage society. The reality is that no class or individual could ever be smart enough to understand all of society.
A new social order can’t only be planned; it also has to be built. And this construction has to happen from the ground up, since social relations don’t form from the top down, as ideas first and realities second. To put it another way: social organization can only be derived from social work, not from a perfectly positioned intellect or from the one true, correct theory.
